| 2023: | Cinderella |
| 2022: | Halfway There Bright Star |
| 2021: | Hair Frenzy Women in Jeopardy! |
| 2020: | No shows due to Covid-19 Pandemic |
| 2019: | Sister Act A Grand Night for Singing Steel Magnolias |
| 2018: | 9 to 5 – The Musical Crimes of the Heart |
| 2017: | Mary Poppins Wonder of the World |
| 2016: | Iolanthe Indoor/Outdoor |
| 2015: | Mikado Sundays without Scenery: Grey Gardens Mrs. Mannerly Other Desert Cities The World Goes Round |
| 2014: | Pirates of Penzance Sundays without Scenery: The Baby Dance Almost Maine Miracle on 34th Street |
| 2013: | HMS Pinafore Motherhood Out Loud You’re A Good Man Charlie Brown (revised) |
| 2012: | Sex in the Sixties: An Evening of FourPlay(s) The Sweetest Sounds Harvey |
| 2011: | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum On Golden Pond Rabbit Hole |
| 2010: | Once Upon a Mattress The Imaginary Invalid Oliver Doubt |
| 2009: | Manny’s War Gypsy Barefoot in the Park Annie Get Your Gun |
| 2008: | Cinderella A Hand for Murder Sisters Rosensweig The Odd Couple (female) Guys and Dolls |
| 2007: | Jacques Brel is Alive and Well and Living in Paris Miracle on 34th Street The Sound of Music Five Women Wearing the Same Dress Bye Bye Birdie |
| 2006: | I Hate Hamlet Nunsense Cricket on the Hearth Plaza Suite Oklahoma! |
| 2005: | Present Laughter A Dickens of a Christmas Carol LCCT’s Dead of Winter Series Ah, Wilderness! HMS Pinafore |
| 2004: | Lend Me a Tenor LCCT’s Dead of Winter Series Steel Magnolias Annie |
| 2003: | Our Town The Xmas Files No No Nanette Out of the Frying Pan Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat |
| 2002: | A Talent for Murder The Best Christmas Pageant Ever Brigadoon The Fantasticks |
| 2001: | Moon Over Buffalo Charlie Brown The Dining Room King & I |
| 2000: | Cat on a Hot Tin Roof Pirates of Penzance Love Changes Everything The Cripple of Inishmaan Anything Goes |
| 1999: | A Musical Trip to Broadway Zeno’s Arrow Sylvia Into the Woods Sondheim & Company |
| 1998: | Come Back Little Sheba My Fair Lady Jesus Christ Superstar The Music Man |
| 1997: | The Mikado Say It with Music Kiss Me Kate The Rainmaker Secret Garden |
| 1996: | Other People’s Money Damn Yankees Vox Populi: One Act Plays Candide |
| 1995: | Carousel Big River Lettice & Lovage |
| 1994: | It’s a Wonderful Life A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum The Importance of Being Earnest The Apple Tree |
| 1993: | The Taming of the Shrew The Most Happy Fella You Can’t Take It With You The Old Lady Shows Her Medals & Rise and Shine |
| 1992: | The Haunting of Hill House Finian’s Rainbow A Midsummer Night’s Dream |
| 1991: | Fiddler on the Roof The Little Foxes Folk & Fancy |
| 1990: | Anne of Green Gables A Man for All Seasons Annie |
| 1989: | Oliver Our Town Twentieth Century |
| 1988: | Night Must Fall Friends & Lovers Bye Bye Birdie |
| 1987: | Godspell Vaudeville Gold The Man Who Came to Dinner |
| 1986: | The Murder Game The Music Man Wicked Good Band Salt of the Earth It’s a Wonderful Life |
| 1985: | Harvey Company The Wizard of Oz |
| 1984: | I’m a Celebrity Once Upon a Mattress A Christmas Carol |
| 1983: | Old Favorites & New Fancies Guys & Dolls A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum |
| 1982: | Our Town Brigadoon Emperor’s New Clothes |
| 1981: | King and I Murder in the Magnolias |
| 1980: | L’il Abner Fiddler on the Roof A Midsummer Night’s Dream |
| 1979: | Sound of Music See How They Run |
| 1978: | Showboat Oliver |
| 1977: | Camelot HMS Pinafore No Sex Please We’re British |
